AOL. Davis Turner/Bloomberg/Getty Images On Sept. 25, 2009, Bank of America's ( BAC ) own shareholders took it to court . But should they have? Led by large pension funds such as the State Teachers Retirement System of Ohio, the Ohio Public Employees Retirement System and the Teacher Retirement System of Texas, shareholders sued Bank of America for a litany of sins. Not least among them was a claim that the bank had a "secret agreement" to permit Merrill Lynch -- a near-bankrupt stockbroker that Bank of America agreed to buy in the depths of the financial crisis -- to pay its executives up to $5.8 billion in bonuses prior to getting bought. Considering that Merrill racked up more than $15 billion in losses while under these executives' control and that Bank of America itself lost a bundle in the housing market meltdown, Bank of America shareholders were understandably upset. They especially didn't like the fact that Bank of America stock, in the words of the website dedicated to the lawsuit, "plummeted from $12.99 per share to a low of $5.10 per share, causing a market capitalization loss of approximately $50 billion" after these losses were revealed. Open Mouth, Insert Foot, Shoot Self in Foot According to Reuters , what are known as securities class action lawsuits are regaining popularity among investors looking for someone to blame when their investments go south. After peaking during the period of investor outrage over the financial crisis several years ago and declining since, such lawsuits are growing again -- up 9 percent year over year in 2013 to 166 lawsuits filed. But a new report out of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce's Institute for Legal Reform suggests that the shareholders who participate in such lawsuits may be making a costly mistake. As the institute explains, securities class action lawsuits, such as the one Bank of America shareholders filed, cost investors nearly $39 billion per year by driving down the stock prices of the companies sued, but the compensation that investors get from suing their companies is only $5 billion. Now, $5 billion is a whole lot more than the aggrieved shareholders of Bank of America may wind up receiving. According to the terms of their settlement agreement with the bank, the "$50 billion" in market capitalization that plaintiffs alleged was lost will be compensated with a settlement amount of just $2.4 billion. That's less than a nickel for each dollar of losses the investors suffered. Back to Square One That doesn't sound very fair to the investors. But really, they have no one but themselves to blame. According to the institute's study, the instant investors set out to sue a company for stock market losses, the stock loses 4.4 percent of its market cap on average. That 4.4 percent loss of market cap is almost equal to the 4.8 percent settlement amount that Bank of America shareholders, for example, will win from their litigation. Put another way, the end result of shareholders suing their company to recover losses is years of litigation, followed by a refund of only those losses the shareholder incurred by filing the lawsuit. Who Profits? Shareholders, as we've seen, lose twice from securities class action lawsuits: First, when the stock goes down due to malfeasance by the company they invested in. Second, when the stock goes down even more in response to the filing of a lawsuit. adsonar_placementId=1505951;adsonar_pid=1990767;adsonar_ps=-1;adsonar_zw=242;adsonar_zh=252;adsonar_jv='ads.tw.adsonar.com'; The pennies-on-the-dollar they recover, on average, after years of litigation, are only sufficient to compensate shareholders for the second drop -- and do nothing to compensate them for the stock-drop that prompted them to join the lawsuit in the first place. So who profits? The lawyers who file the suits. They suffered nothing from the stock's decline (because they never owned it), and they collect an average of 18 percent of any legal settlement as their fee. And of course, this comes out of the money that would otherwise have gone to the shareholders. The Moral of the Story When a company gets caught doing something underhanded, and it gets sued, some investors' natural instinct is to do two things: First, sue. Second, sell the stock so that if they win the lawsuit, they won't own the company that has to pay for the loss. The study proves that this is generally a self-defeating strategy. A better strategy? Unless the company's business is in real shambles, stick around as it fixes its business -- or buy more shares. After all, while Bank of America's former shareholders may win a few pennies on the dollar from their lawsuit against the company, shareholders who stuck out the crisis are today sitting on more than a 200 percent profit off the $5.10 share price that Bank of America hit during the crisis. The stock's price as of this writing?: $17.21. Motley Fool contributor Rich Smith has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Bank of America. The Motley Fool owns shares of Bank of America . Filed under: Company News , Banks , Financial Services , Scandals and Lawsuits When Shareholders Sue, Even When They Win, They Lose originally appeared on DailyFinance.com on Wed, 02 Apr 2014 10:00:00 EST. Please see our terms for use of feeds . Nokia says gets Chinese approval to sell phone business to... Europe's Top Court Rules 2006 Telecoms Data Retention Law Is... Indiegogo Updates Its Logo And Redesigns Website, Finally... Free Now Wants To Acquire Bouygues Telecom To Become A Telecom... More from TechCrunch FAQ Site Map Search Site Apps RSS Videos Feedback AOL Money & Finance. © Copyright 2014 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved NYSE, NASDAQ and NYSE MKT data delayed 15 minutes. Real-Time prices provided by BATS. Market data provided by Interactive Data. Powered and implemented by Interactive Data Managed Solutions. Obama wanted poster Soccer cancer slogans Dr in greensboro that gives hcg shots 1978 dodge class b xplorer motorhome Foster s home for imaginary friends hentai Long island railroad to hicksville Medication sheet for assited living Letras pegadas de abecedario Rick anthony bowers Fake credit card numbers that work for netflix Nursing interventions for ativan Funny wagers with friends Bible verses on people who volunteer Batman symbol alt code Toxic junction gore Class reunion banquet agenda Blank certificate with border Inspirational poems breast cancer Tfunny 21st speeches best friend Girl signatures for phone Dirty names to call someone Tnetspend reload pack codes Tkeno results victoriaeno tesult of v Contemporary entertainment centers for flat screen tvs Colleague going away lunch invitation wording Efy sheet music Adolescent residential treatment facilities in dallas texas Positive adjectives beginning with w Adam killian myspace Stories of glory holes and their customers Mabey johnson bridge manuall Book report on farenhiet 413 Twhat is the best paper to put a funeral resolution on Tcan amitriptyline be taken with tramadolan amitriptyline be taken with Inexpensive scandinavian furniture Create your own bmx bikesx Alcohol carbohydrate content in Catchy online dating headlines examples What happened to randy dave Missouri division of alcohol Best big game hunting rifle Memorial monument sayings Imvu nude code Dedicatorias de baby shower en espanol Good bye cards Cojiendo a mi ermana Student nipple sliptudent nipple slip Terrible 20 line poems Tattoo ideas ford brothers Read maya angelou graduation Beth phoenix naked Lung cancer ribbon necklace Pictures of tiny before plastic surgery My dish red lobster .com Aboutyou. verizonwireless.com Milena vela barbeque Ffa sayings for shirts Wendy will game fowl farm Tobjective skills for sales associate Tfree ashley madison credits 7 minutes in heaven quiz long resultsl Marrying older woman Hedonism party pictures Lady alexis escort review Cash flow statement sample questions answers Myspace camera symbol Jlmenau and kobalt Ninel conde boob sizeinel conde boob size Is chanel west cost dating steelo brim Prilosec with maalox Itune gifts Letter home to parents living things Care for bobwhite quail pen design Free pattern for newborn elf hats Tsales plan presentation examples Motherload game at school Sharp pains in your lower abdomen upper vagina when Free wood shed plans Kendra knight poop How to apply external male catheter Fifth grade thanksgiving scavenger hunt Craftsman hydrostatic parts diagram Free spiderman cutoutsm Toddlercon rapeoddlercon rape Free clip art theatre ushers Mdma kitchen sink Patient administration of fosamax Mom mastur son Ls-models pictures Telementary school student council election Lamb the band Quick ligase enzyme Shark in a blue lagoon flash games Google play gift card code generator apkoogle play gift card code Labeled diagram human cell Really simple first message online dating Level e vocab answers Desiging your own bmx bike Tis shannon bream a democrat Hipaa compliance forms for employees florida Used safari condo alto for sale Mobius unleashed comicsobius unleashed comics Aim smiley faces codes Lime green zebra bedding Craigslist cedar rapids Metric engineering inc. miami fla Unwanted rap lyrics Nato enlisted ranks Toilet slaves in action Tmandees application form Madness interactive star wars modsx Ijas sedusiendo a sus padres Mazda rx 8 r3 specs Fairy fortune slot machine free Free worksheets on the thirteen colonies Batino elementary school Boat for sale in t Vocab level f unit 1-3 review Red halo hen night Gun made from text Honorary membership certificate template Endocrine hormones flowchart Mexican gives good head Current price of aluminum cans cincinnati A list of indian names and their meanings Where to buy jenny reviera jeans Imagenes para mi blackberry Green zebra youth bedding Frases para invitaciones baby shower Rrh guide 29 Medication administration record sheet Melbourne sister city Random drug and alcohol testing info Best cna resume samples Free pictureview account Zibu symbols of sisters Fotos cachondas de putas jovencitas Funny track poems Binweevil.com gamecard Lsd den in wales 197os police Twhere can i get a free download of the iso7x exercise wall chart pdf Which sudafed pill is the most powerful Vocabulary for interests & hobbies in resumes Madre folla a su hijo videos Custom birth certificate template Mom help daughter sex Redtube large forehead Brother birthday sayings Stomach gambling after meals Tminecraft servers 1.3. 2 hunger games Petition letter of appeal sample Medical assistant resume cover letter samples Long layered hairstyles with side swept bangsong layered Nikwax tent & gear proof How much for a checkup at medexpress Digimon masters adult kssn Read cbr ipad goodreader Letter to best friend on her 20th birthdayetter to best friend on her 20th birthday Getting rid of cotinine Moparscape codes database Mix adderall and focalin Free printable letters for bulletin boards Bleach 30 minutes in heavenleach 30 Tcertified dental billing resume examples Taper fade thats not too short Personal injury demand letter template Catriona rowntree nip slip pics Madness interactive german Birthday quotes for girls Plavix and alcohol consumption Middle school reading passages Local newspaper atlanta ga Love football game Poems about a deceased loved ones birthday Madres follando con sus hijos en videos Abiotic factors in antarticabiotic factors in antartica Tnike elite socks bulk Forced inpregnation stories Company resume templates Concrete park bench design Black mens goatees Club penguin igloo generator download page Design you own bmx Fotos natalia villaveces Metric conversion song Malawi major industries Bangla magi choda video Truyen thep den Renting a car in santiago chile Role of satellites in communication High school lesson plan blank Farewell new job wishes Health meridia system Texample good administrative assistant resume Make a joint using keyboard Boca miniplus ticket printers Afro side fade Free flute worksheets for beginners Killeen bankruptcy lawyer email e-mail Dean martin casino slots
留言列表
